Footpath Vendors and Rape - Where's the Connection?

The Dr. Rustom Soonawalla Rape Case

Rape is a horrible offence but this case of rape seems to be full of holes. Isn’t a man innocent until proven guilty? And proven guilty, not by the police, nor politicians with an agenda, especially not by newspapers whose main concern is their TRP, but by the justice system?

In this episode the alleged rape victim had TB and was cured by Dr. Soonawalla. She had come for a check up with her husband. Some newspapers say the husband claims that the doctor sent him out and raped his wife at his clinic in Khar at 7 pm. Others say the husband received a phone call on his mobile and went out to answer the call. In any case, the accuser's husband went out of the room while his wife was being examined. That is when, the accuser claims, the rape occured.

This is what strikes me as odd. There are a lot of hawkers outside the doc's clinic. The husband was either in the waiting room as was the receptionist or he was outside the clinic amongst the hawkers. Yet nobody heard a thing.

Also, the woman had TB - no one was more aware of that than the doctor. According to this article she was 99% cured.

TB, according to wikipedia, is a lethal infectious disease. Wiki's exact words,
Tuberculosis, MTB, or TB (short for tubercle bacillus) is a common, and in many cases lethal, infectious disease caused by various strains of mycobacteria, usually Mycobacterium tuberculosis... Treatment is difficult ... Social contacts are also screened and treated if necessary.

Knowing that, would he, a doctor, have raped her? Raped someone who still had that 1% chance of having TB? To my mind he wouldn't have touched her except to treat her out of compassion as a doctor. Dr. Soonawalla was known to do a lot of social service.

As for the newspapers - this is what they initially said - that he ran away and has disappeared. One account from the Indian Express, (nine days later), states the police had no search or arrest warrant. Yet they went to his residence and told him that his clinic had been broken into and that he should accompany them to the clinic (or police station - not sure). On the way one constable, who was in Dr. Soonawalla's car, told him it was nothing to do with his clinic but that he was being arrested for rape. That is when the doctor called his lawyer who instructed him not to go to the police station. The police had no concrete forensic evidence as yet - no blood or semen samples from the site, for example. Makes one wonder on whose instructions they were acting. Besides, people have the perception that once inside a police station, they can be roughed up by the police - guilty or not guilty doesn't enter the picture. Following his lawyer's instructions, Dr. Soonawalla left the two constables on the roadside and drove off. His lawyer, Ponda, has said that he has promised to come forward and give his semen and blood samples - something no guilty person would be willing to do, provided the police don't arrest him at the hospital. 

The Hindustan Times states that a case was registered at around 9.30pm on Friday. A medical test to confirm rape was conducted on the alleged victim, the result of which is awaited. Forensic evidence was collected from the doctor's clinic by a team of experts.

I searched to see what the Times of India had to say and surprisingly, couldn't find anything till the 4th of June. Perhaps I'm mistaken. Later I discovered an article in the Mumbai Mirror (a Mobile e-paper of the Times of India) titled, "Police pick holes in rape charges against Khar doc on the run" 

And here's one from the Mumbai Mirror - Activists Rally behind Khar doc, police await medical report.

Apparently, Anjali Damania of the AAP has demanded that the doctor be arrested and the two policemen who let him get away be charged. Mayank Gandhi - another AAP member and also a builder, wrote in his blog about the complainant that when he first met her he could see she was telling the truth - that he could see it in her face. What kind of evidence is that? Here’s AAP's account of what happened on their fb, Maharashtra site: https://www.facebook.com/AAPMaharashtra/posts/646191792061262 and there are comments from a huge number of the doctor's patients vouching for his integrity. 

One of the comments for the doctor states that - This is all completely fabricated. Dr Soonawala is a very emminent and respected doctor of the community. He has been working for the poor near his place of practice for years. There were a lot of hawkers where he practices and when he asked them repeatedly to move out from that place which was illegally occupied by them, they approached the local politicians and in order to teach the poor doctor, they have filed this wrong rape case on him.

This will have no bearing on the case as in no way can it be proved. But it makes one wonder. If it is true - if the local politician pitted the vendors against the doctor I hope the Aam Aadmi Party resists the temptation to do the same. Siding with the accusers without listening to the defence is doing just that.

I haven't yet seen Arvind Kejriwal censuring his party members for demanding punishment for Dr. Soonawalla without any hard evidence presented in court. I believe the entire Parsi community, ardent supporters of the AAP, moved away because of this one incident which is sad for the AAP. But I've heard rumours that the AAP censured them and stopped them from yelling RAPE outside the altruistic doctor's clinic. This is backed up by the fact that suddenly, overnight, Mayank and Anjali stopped these reprehensible and daily picketing activities outside Dr. Soonawalla's clinic. [A few years on - Anjali Damania and Mayank Gandhi are both out of the AAP.]

If India is to become a land that upholds justice so that crooked individuals aren't able to flourish, everyone, whether rich or poor, has to see that justice isn't in the hands of politicians but is part of the judicial system. Dr. Soonawalla's lawyer is right to demand he be tried through the justice system and not be arrested by the police without proper warrants.

The Bigger Picture: Hawkers were a convenience at one time. One didn't have to go far to buy whatever one wanted and cheaper. But now they are spreading to occupy every inch of every footpath. They, naturally, want to continue plying their wares - legally or illegally. They don't care if they make certain places inaccessible - perhaps even dirty.

People who pay rent to carry on a legitimate business expect that their place of work should remain accessible to their clients. They also hope that it remains reasonably clean. [I won't even begin to discuss the garbage piles or people setting up abode on our footpaths and where they go for their daily ablutions.]

In such a scenario, how would justice be done? Simply by ensuring hawkers have a proper place to ply their wares and people who pay rent are ensured access to their work place. Instead politicians play one set off against the other as long as they have the power to be the arbiters of justice and to decide who gets what. That is not justice. It is concentration of power in the wrong hands.

Life is being choked out of our cities - they have two-story-high garbage dumps, slum cities within their confines, footpaths that are used for anything but walking.

As Bhagu says about the attractions of our city in Never Mind Yaar - "…our beaches - the sound of the sea - if we can reach it, that is, through the obstacle course of vendors and beggars; our parks and playgrounds … …taken over by,” he shook his head ruefully, “… the same vendors and beggars;"

Our politicians have, yet again, failed to see the bigger picture. Not one of them addresses the real issue - that of attempting to plan our cities and take the reality on the ground into account - in this case, by giving illegal vendors proper areas to ply their wares which doesn't obstruct access to legitimate businesses.

The success of our cities is to ensure the success of both.



.

Why Some People are Sceptical about the AAP

It is official. It’s the Aam Aadmi Party – the AAP. Why would it be good for the nation? 

First, the party hopes to address corruption. And second, they intend that there will be no muzzling of the aam aadmi. They have a proven track record. They’ve invited honest feedback while others have tried to muzzle the opinions of the common citizens of India. Ordinary people have gone to jail for daring to criticise political parties and their leaders. Rule by fear.

Still, there are some people who are wary of giving the AAP a chance. They want change with all their hearts. They hate the corruption they face daily. They know what it has done to the nation. 

But these are some of the things that stop them. There’s the fear of the unknown. They don’t wish to take a chance with a new party. They’d rather settle for whatever is known. At least it has constancy – they know how to handle the corruption and they know they have to pay up – whatever the price – if they want daal roti or anything legitimate done for themselves. Who knows what might be brought into the equation through unknowns? 

• It doesn’t matter that the known parties are trying to muzzle the ordinary citizens and sending them to jail for voicing their opinions. 
• It doesn’t matter that thanks to corruption in individual members of existing parties many Indians have remained mired in poverty with a complete lack of health, education, shelter, food, clothing and employment. 
• There have been scams to make land grabs legitimate. This has resulted in suicide and depression. 
• The corruption perception index puts India at 3.1 out of 10
• the air we breathe, the soil we grow our produce in or let our cattle graze in and our drinking water makes ours an environmentally poor country to grow up in. 

We would rather take all that than take a chance with a new party.

We are meek and submissive as our current politicians want us to be. How was it possible to put those ordinary individuals in jail? We could all see that state machinery was used - for example, the police. Who had the power to call on that state machinery to do their bidding? Do we have to be scared of passing our opinions? Or is it something we are used to anyway so where's the problem?

And last, but not least, there’s apathy. “It is hot, I am busy, I hate politics, we'll always have corruption in politics or how will just one vote – mine – make such a difference” are all excuses we use to remain apathetic.

My hope is that come election time each and every Indian will know and appreciate not only Arvind but all the AAP party members of which there are 300 right now. 

Here are some of the things I appreciate in Arvind - the AAP leader. He has an elephantine memory. Politicians have tried everything in their power to bring him down but he’s always come back with facts and figures to confound their efforts. They’ve made accusations that he is self serving; that he wants to enter politics for himself; that he’s simply using the platform of corruption for his personal ambitions. His response has been to let them know he's only joined politics to fight the system from within. He, Anna and so many Indians tried letting politicians (of all parties) know how much the aam aadmi hated their corrupt ways. This was without wanting to join politics but through peaceful protests. The response from politicians was to pretend they were agreed to bringing in a law to punish corrupt politicians. Their version of that law, as we all know, was to once again put themselves in charge of the investigations against themselves.

I’d like to close this post by talking about Anna and Arvind. They are two sides of the same coin. Arvind’s move of forming a political party has Anna’s blessings. Anna has promised to campaign for Arvind’s party members as long as they are not corrupt.  The 2 As make the most perfect foil for each other. Both have the good of their country at heart. Anna likes working with his hands. Who isn’t impressed with the way he’s turned his village from abject poverty into prosperity. Not for him the complexities of the letter of the law and debates. Those are in the capable hands of someone with a memory for facts and figures - the articulate Arvind Kejriwal and his Aam Aadmi Party.

Note: The Aam Aadmi Party website has pages under the title “Agenda” that explain exactly what they are planning to tackle and how. Watch this video to find out what you can do to join the party, what pamphlets you can distribute etc.